Review: The Case of Bingley’s Missing Aphrodite by Emma Aubrey

Title: The Case of Bingley’s Missing Aphrodite
Author: Emma Aubrey
Publication Date: September 3, 2026
Publisher: Emma Aubrey
Format Read: Kindle e-book
Genre: Mystery, Historical Fiction


The Case of Bingley’s Missing Aphrodite came to my attention through someone I follow on Goodreads, who rated it 5 stars. It is also touted as a reimagining of Pride & Prejudice mixed with Sherlock Holmes. This tracks. I love historical fiction and mysteries, so I suspected I would enjoy it.

The story begins with Fitzwilliam Darcy and his younger sister attending a party his best friend, Bingley, is hosting. Bingley has been in low spirits ever since Darcy advised him against becoming involved with Jane Bennet. At the party, Bingley’s recently acquired Aphrodite statue vanishes. It is there before supper, then gone when it is time for the dancing to begin. Darcy and Bingley enlist the help of Mr. Bennet, cousin to the Bennet sisters, to locate the statue. When they meet with him, Mr. Bennet has just learned that a viscount who lives near Darcy was murdered that same night, and he realizes the statue may be connected to the murder.

This was quite a fun read! Darcy is very… Darcy. He is proper and sometimes struggles to recognize humor, but he is a good, honest fellow whose heart is always in the right place. I found Mr. Bennet utterly fascinating from start to finish. He is so very clever. The mystery itself intrigued me and held my interest until the very end.

Aubrey balances a Regency setting with a more modern, playful writing style that made this a quick and enjoyable read. The banter is sharp, especially between Mr. Bennet and Darcy, but the story also leaves room for more sincere emotional moments. Beneath the mystery are themes of truth versus deception, reputation, class expectations, and the ways women are underestimated, all of which fit naturally within this reimagining of Austen’s characters.

I am genuinely looking forward to the next installment in this series. I would recommend it to readers who enjoy historical mysteries. It is also a good step between cozy mysteries and darker historical mysteries, as there are no scenes of gore and it remains generally polite throughout.

Nerd Rating: 🤓🤓🤓🤓— A clever and charming Regency mystery


Click here to learn more about The Case of Bingley’s Missing Aphrodite and Emma Aubrey.


Let’s Discuss:
What classic story would you love to see reimagined as a mystery?


Support Indie Booksellers

Thinking about picking up a copy? Purchasing through the link below supports independent bookstores, and I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting indie booksellers and I Speak Book Nerd. 💛🤓📚💛

Get your copy on Bookshop.org.

This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Reply